Tech Articles

What’s the Difference Between Single- & Dual-Circuit Brake Systems? (And Why You Need to Know the Distinction!)

It’s a big “duh” to say that brakes are vitally important to your driving safety.

Yet, while hydraulic brake systems have been around for over a century now, if you’re thinking about buying or restoring a classic vehicle, there are still some very important questions to consider:

Does it have a dual- or single-circuit hydraulic brake system? And what does that mean to the vehicle’s drivability?

We’ll explore the answers in a moment—but first, some history.

Early Automotive Brake Systems

At the dawn of the automobile, brakes were alarmingly basic.

How basic? Some simply had a hand lever that would push a wood block against the wheel hub (yikes). And you could forget about having brakes at all four wheels, many of the first cars had just a single set of friction brakes on one axle.

Even with the advent of drum brakes at each corner, these early brake systems were completely mechanical, often connected via a cable or bands. And anyone who’s ever fiddled with a wonky parking brake cable knows that those are prone to stretching, seizing, and braking…err…breaking.

Adequate for something like a 20 horsepower Model T, but perhaps a bit sketchy for a Flathead V8-powered 1932 Ford.

Introducing Hydraulics

Meet Blaise Pascal, a French physicist born in 1623. In addition to being one of the fathers of the modern computer, he figured out some key concepts in fluid mechanics. His work gave way to a string of advancements in hydraulics, which culminated in the first patent for a hydraulic automobile braking system by Malcolm Loughead in 1917.

Blaise Pascal—physicist, theologian, and (presumed) gearhead. (Image/Commons.Wikimedia)

In a vehicle’s brake system, hydraulics had a ton of upside. Thanks to the force amplification behind Pascal’s Law, it made the pedal easier to press. Better still, it exerted pressure evenly, and the hydraulic system was compact and relatively easy to integrate into a vehicle chassis.

Problem was, it was tough to get right.

Seal materials, pressure fittings, chemistry—it took several manufacturers working to perfect hydraulic braking over the next two decades before hydraulic brakes found mass adoption. Once they nailed it though, consumers immediately felt the advantages of the improved hydraulic brake design.

It should be noted that we’re still mostly talking about drum brakes here. While several manufactures (ahem…Crosley…ahem) had experimented with hydraulic disc brake systems, drums were the most common, by far. We’ll get to disc brakes a bit near the bottom of this article.)

What is a Single-Circuit Hydraulic Drum Brake System?

Here’s a simplified illustration of a very basic single-circuit drum/drum brake system—the kind that was common on cars during the 1950s. (Image/OnAllCylinders)

Single-circuit brakes use a single system of brake lines, all connected together, actuated by a piston within the brake system’s master cylinder. When the brake pedal is applied, the piston is pushed into the master cylinder, which, thanks to that Pascal guy we talked about earlier, will transfer the pressure evenly to each of the four drum brakes.

Now, the illustration above is simplified…but it ain’t that simplified. The lines were typically joined using basic T-fittings and, save for the use of residual valves to maintain slight pressure at each wheel, each brake line terminates at the drum’s wheel cylinder.

While this single-circuit setup was effective, it had one serious problem—and it’s a flaw inherent within any hydraulic system. When you lose hydraulic pressure, the system is almost immediately rendered useless. So, say you’re driving along in a 1950s-era cruiser, you tear a brake line on a piece of road debris and, after a couple of stabs on the brake pedal, you’ve got little to no stopping power.

That’s why many hydraulic systems build-in some sort of redundancy to prevent against a total pressure loss.

And that’s…

Why Automakers Switched to Dual-Circuit Drum Brake Systems

A dual-circuit brake system uses separate brake circuits for the front and rear brake drums, acting as a kind of redundancy to avoid total brake loss. (Image/OnAllCylinders)

The obvious play here was to build in some sort of redundancy to the hydraulic brake system. But running a complete parallel system would’ve added a significant layer of complexity to the automobile, so engineers devised a simple solution: treat both the front and rear axles as independent circuits.

In a dual-circuit brake system, the front hydraulic lines and brake components are completely isolated from the rears. That means, if the front brakes suffered a catastrophic pressure loss, the driver could still rely on the rear brakes to bring the vehicle to a stop (or vice versa).

While there’s still a noticeable loss of stopping power, it’s way, way better than losing all hydraulic pressure. And since the driver can instantly sense there’s something awry, it allows them to safely slow the vehicle the minute a problem is detected.

And believe it or not, that system is still very much in use today—albeit tweaked somewhat when disc brakes became the preferred front brake design. So let’s talk about that.

Dual-Circuit Drum/Disc Brake Systems

Though Pascal’s hydraulic principles remain the same, using a hybrid drum/disc brake system required the addition of specialized valves. (Image/OnAllCylinders)

When automobile manufacturers begin to adopt front disc brakes in earnest during the mid-to-late 1960s, it presented a problem to the traditional dual-circuit brake system. Given the different physical operation of drums and discs, it meant that Pascal’s Law of evenly-applied hydraulic pressure hits a snag. To meet the slightly slower response of drums versus discs, engineers installed a metering valve downstream from the master cylinder. It essentially delays the discs for a split-second to allow the drums to engage at the same time.

But there was another issue too. The design differences between the two brake types meant that drums were subject to increased pressure during panic stops. This often resulted in drivers locking-up the rear drums during those hard stops. That’s a pretty big deal, because when the brakes lock up, stopping power is greatly decreased and the driver risks losing control of the vehicle.

A brake proportioning valve addresses this issue. Like a metering valve, it’s put downstream, immediately after the master cylinder. The valve decreases brake pressure to the drums during high pressure spikes (like when you stab the brake pedal in a panic stop).

You’ll typically find a brake proportioning valve and metering valve in vehicles with a disc front, drum rear setup–often combined into a single valve assembly. While they’re technically called combination valves, you’ll likely hear them simply referred to as proportioning valves.

On stock setups, the proportioning valve is usually permanently set from the factory. But for performance- and race-oriented vehicles, proportioning valves are often adjustable. That capability allows the driver to fine-tune the vehicles’ front/rear brake bias.

How do I Know If I Have a Single- or Dual-Circuit Brake System?

In 1967, the U.S. federal government mandated dual-circuit brake systems in all new vehicles. So, if your car is a 1967 model year or newer, then it’ll likely have a dual-circuit brake system. But even before that, some vehicles had begun using a dual-circuit setup. The good news is, if you’re unsure, it’s probably going to be really easy to check.

Here’s a single-circuit brake master cylinder inside the frunk of a restored, stock 1962 Chevy Corvair. Note the single brake line extending down into the bulkhead. (Image/OnAllCylinders)

Pop your hood and find your master cylinder. It’ll typically be bolted to the firewall near the brake pedal (on the opposite side). Once you locate it, take a look at how many brake lines exit the assembly. If there’s only one, then you’ve got a single-circuit system, if there’s two, then it’s a dual-circuit system.

Here’s a typical master cylinder from a domestic vehicle made between 1967 and, say, 1980ish with disc brakes in the front, drums in the rear. The two hard brake lines exiting the assembly mean this is a dual-circuit brake system. Note that the master cylinder actually has two separate fluid reservoirs here, indicated by the two distinct bumps on the master cylinder lid. (Image/OnAllCylinders – Paul Sakalas)

It’s worth pointing out that earlier dual brake systems often maintained two distinct fluid reservoirs within the master cylinder housing. This meant that you’d have to monitor both brake fluid levels. While this dual-reservoir setup was, at worst, a minor inconvenience, disc/disc vehicles nowadays usually just have a single reservoir that both circuits draw fluid from.

This is a modern master cylinder for a Subaru Outback with both front and rear disc brakes. Note it maintains the two distinct hard lines for either brake circuit, yet has a single plastic brake fluid reservoir instead of the large cast iron dual-reservoir master cylinder pictured above. (Image/OnAllCylinders – Paul Sakalas)

I Have a Single-Circuit Brake System, Should I Change it to a Dual-Circuit System?

For starters, do you drive the vehicle often? If it’s a regular cruiser than you should seriously consider retrofitting a dual-circuit brake system. It’s a vital and sensible modification that can go a long way towards mitigating a catastrophic brake failure. While all vehicles are different, in many situations, the conversion is relatively straightforward, so don’t expect to chop up your vehicle body or drill a bunch of extra holes. And there will be very little visual impact—if you’re worried about the vintage aesthetic of your engine bay, a dual-circuit master cylinder swap is relatively innocuous.

Again depending on your vehicle, a dual-circuit conversion could be as simple as replacing the master cylinder and running some extra hard line. That’s assuming, of course, your vehicle has a drum/drum brake setup. Obviously if you’re contemplating a disc brake conversion kit, you’ll have to upgrade to a dual-circuit system anyway.

Honestly, the only real reason we can think of to retain a single-circuit brake system is in situations were originality or period-correctness is critical. You probably don’t want to upset the originality of something like a high-dollar concours car. But for most classic cruisers, a dual-circuit brake system is almost always a sensible, prudent upgrade.

Tags: , , , , , ,

2 Comments

  1. Pingback: 2021 Muscle Car Match-Ups Winner: The Chevy C-/K-Series Squarebody Pickup Truck!

  2. Pingback: Don't Forget to Check & Fill Your Hydraulic Clutch Fluid: Here's How

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.